Michael didn't articulate his principles the way Doyle and Sam did in those other movies, but it's the same thing. It's his consistent M. No matter how long he has to wait, he always kills whomever has betrayed or attacked the family. He waited until their mother was dead because he was also principled enough to take her into consideration.
Just before Mikael says the famous quote easy to find on YouTube, saying "you are not my brother", there are explanations. And Mikael is under trial.
And he asks Fredo if he can tell him something about the investigation. And Fredo says that the Senate lawyer Questadt belongs to Roth. It it seems like Mikael feels betrayed again. For example Pantageli was tricked by Roth to believe that Mikael tried to kill him so that he can testify at court against Michael funnily he will do the opposite since he is an oldie friend of Vitto and his brother is present at the court maybe as a threat or reminder of good care of him.
And probably that Fredo does not say enough there. Maybe he expected that Mikael will lose the trial and get more place in the family and the mafia clans. That is what is awesome about this film. So many returnings of what we believe. You really have to dig deep to explain.
I also think Fredo does too much the tough guy in the video above. Mikael is not impulsive and disliked it. Fredo Corleone's concealing of Questadt's allegiance was part of the reason why he was expelled from the Corleone family.
I think there are several possibilities, not mutually exclusive. The one that is raised most often here is Michael's hard-heartedness after his transformation is complete by the end of Part II. But I think that's only one part of the puzzle. Remember that "mafioso" literally means "men of honor.
While the book is not canon to the film, it does give hints as to the state of mind of Puzo and by extension that of close collaborator Coppola with respect to these characters.
To this end, then, let us ponder Tom Hagan's page-side explaination as to why Michael had killed Carlo and Tessio - despite having already incapacitated those who would have pushed them to betray the family and being particularly fond of this latter - and ponder whether the same might not apply to Fredo:.
Michael could have forgiven it, but people never forgive themselves and so they would always be dangerous. Michael really liked Tessio. He loves his sister. But he would be shirking his duty to you and his children, to his whole family, to me and my family, if he let Tessio and Carlo go free.
They would have been a danger to us all, all our lives. By analogy, I propose that Michael killed Fredo above all because his beliefs dictated that in such circumstances there was simply no other choice.
Perhaps it is debatable whether the prospect of letting his own blood would have made him rethink his values had he not been so coldhearted, and this I think is where Michael's transformation might be pertinent. Sign up to join this community. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top. Stack Overflow for Teams — Collaborate and share knowledge with a private group. Create a free Team What is Teams? Learn more.
Why did Michael Corleone not forgive his brother Fredo? Ask Question. Asked 5 years ago. Active 7 months ago. Viewed 86k times. Michael Corleone : You believed that story? You believed that? Fredo: He said there was somethin' in it for me. On my own. Fredo did not know that Roth would try to kill Michael: Fredo: Mike. I swear to God, I didn't know it was gonna be a hit. Fredo wasn't lying.
Fredo: You guys lied to me. I don't want to talk to you anymore. Improve this question. Erba Aitbayev. Erba Aitbayev Erba Aitbayev 1 1 gold badge 6 6 silver badges 13 13 bronze badges.
Related: What exactly did Fredo do to betray Michael? It's no coincidence that he's the middle brother in families already plays the "unappreciated" role , and it begets bitterness and jealousy, so when the opportunity presents itself Add a comment. Active Oldest Votes. Improve this answer. Carlo used to abuse his sister and was in the conspiracy to kill Sonny. So there are three main differences here: 1 Carlo was no blood related 2 His action got his brother killed 3 He used to beat Michael's sister — aaa.
Was going to say, should be edited to state that he admitted betraying Sonny. It's still business, but the business there is that any attempt on a member of the family will mean death to all involved, in which case Fredo and Carlo do fit in the same category. Probably not a bad general rule to have everyone out there know about if killing people is a regular part of the business transactions. I have to respectfully disagree.
Fredo was appointed sotto capo , or underboss , by his brother, an appointment that was seen as unqualified nepotism, though Fredo was given little real power and the title was mostly ceremonial.
Michael Corleone's rivals, chiefly Louie Russo , the mob boss of Chicago , hoped to exploit this rumor of Fredo's bisexuality to make Michael look weak. Though hesitant at first, Fredo paid her three thousand dollars to tell Johnny it was the best sex she ever had, before eventually succumbing and sleeping with her.
Shortly after, with Fredo's knowledge, Marguerite had a baby , whom she put up for adoption. The Corleone family would be able to buy up the former cemetery land cheap, now prime real estate, and also be a silent partner in the graveyard business. Fredo would propose this plan to Michael and impress him, reassuring him and others of his abilities.
To Fredo's dismay, however, Michael dismissed the idea as unrealistic. At the Christmas of , Fredo showed up at the Corleone Christmas party with Deanna Dunn , a famous but fading movie starlet. A few months later they got married. Dunn got Fredo to make appearances in bit parts in some of her movies.
Later, in September , Fredo's Hollywood connections allowed him to get his own successful TV show, "The Fred Corleone Show", which aired irregularly, usually on Monday nights, until his death in , on a local television station in Nevada. Fredo's drinking problems continued and accelerated.
One day, he discovered Deanna cheating on him with her movie co-star Matt Marshall , and Fredo shot-up the Corvette he had bought her. When Deanna's co-star tried to attack him, Fredo ended up knocking him unconscious with a pistol whip and went to a local jail. Tom Hagen came to bail him out and got in an argument about Fredo's reckless activity and Tom's blind loyalty to Michael.
Tom again got the charges dropped as self defense after paying off Marshall and the hotel. If Fredo was told they could help him with his Colma vision, he'd do anything to help.
Fredo met with Johnny Ola and supplied him with all the information they needed, especially financial information, about the Corleone family. Fredo ambiguously claimed that his goal in that deal was simply to get something for himself, on his own, and swore that he did not realize he was being used as part of a larger plot to kill his brother. However, in the event of Michael's assassination, Fredo would likely have led the Corleone family, at least as a figurehead. It is unknown if Fredo knew that they planned to assassinate Michael.
Michael discovered Fredo's role in the plot during his trip to Havana, when Fredo let it slip out that he and Johnny Ola had been in Havana together earlier that year and they went to the sex show together. Michael confronted Fredo later and tells his older brother, "You broke my heart. Later, when Michael is being pursued by a Congressional Committee investigating organized crime, he has a talk with Fredo and realizes that Fredo had both withheld important information from him about Hyman Roth's connection with the Committee's lawyer Questadt , was deeply resentful and jealous of Michael's role in the family business as well as the fact that he was treated as an errand boy and that he was stepped over.
Michael therefore disowns and banishes him from the family, although not wanting any harm to happen to him while their mother was still alive.
Upon their mother's death, and at the urging of their sister Connie , Michael relented toward Fredo and seemingly offered reconciliation. However, it was only a deception to draw Fredo in so as to have him murdered by Al Neri. Fredo and his nephew, Michael's son Anthony , developed a relationship with Michael's consent as part of a plan to kill Fredo and were to go fishing on Lake Tahoe.
However, Anthony is called away by Connie, who tells him that his father wants to take him to Reno. Fredo is left alone in the fishing boat with Al Neri and he takes the boat far out onto the lake.
His suspicions prior to his death are left up to interpretation. As Fredo prays the Hail Mary which he claimed brought him luck whilst fishing , Neri shoots him in the back of the head, not knowing that Anthony was watching from his bedroom window. Michael was wracked with guilt over ordering Fredo's murder for the rest of his life.
When Michael had a stroke, he called out for his brother. Michael broke down in tears when confessing the crime to the future Pope, Cardinal Lamberto , in while at the Vatican. It also irreparably harmed Michael's relationship with his son and Kay, who found about it through their son Anthony.
Described as the child Italian parents prayed to the saints for, Fredo was the weakest and least intelligent of the Corleone brothers; his own brother, Michael, dismissed him as weak and stupid. Fredo was also known for being incredibly gullible and making poor decisions, as evidenced by his secret dealings with Johnny Ola, thinking he was helping the family.
As with all Corleones, Fredo had a temper and would lash out at anyone that insulted him or his family, namely his wife. As strong and forceful as these words are, Michael is not done punishing Fredo. At the end of the movie, Michael has his brother murdered. If one had to pick a single climactic moment for the entire trilogy, the murder of Fredo would probably be it.
Murdering a young child may seem extreme, but the plot proves Don Ciccio correct. Vengeance is taken not out of any sense of honor, but as a mode of self-protection. It is a rational, rather than emotional, act. At first, the killing of Fredo seems consistent with this logic, but it may not be. His carelessness, while dangerous, is probably manageable.
0コメント